SELF ARREST vs. SELF BELAY GRIP


A general tip in the interest of mountain safety regarding holding your ice axe in self-belay grip while in terrain where self-arrests may become immediately necessary.


____________________________________________________________________________________



You can’t self-arrest effectively from self-belay grip. The primary purpose of a (classic) mountaineering ice axe (curved or straight) is self-arrest. Holding an ice axe in self-belay mode impedes effective SA.


If you’re carrying and using an ice axe, it’s because you’re on terrain that you could fall down. If you slip and fall on firm névé on a steep slope, you have about 2-5 seconds before you gain too much speed to affect an arrest. You don’t have seconds to spare with a grip-swap, even if you’ve practiced it a lot.


You can still use an ice axe to self-belay while holding it in self-arrest grip, with the added benefit of already being in self-arrest grip; you’re only self-belaying because you think there’s an imminent possibility of falling down a slope, where you’d then need to...self-arrest.


Self-belay grip mostly stems from people thinking the axe is just more comfortable to carry when you rest your palm on the adze of the ax (or on the hammer), but it’s kind of a throw-back to the alpenstock and hobnail boots days; it’s antiquated, unnecessary and prevents immediate arrest.


Regarding pick-forward ice-ax usage

Pick-forward grip is useful on slopes between about 40°-50º (Final 400 on the Mountaineers Route, for example), but in that type of terrain, especially with a modern, curved shafted axe with a trigrest, you’re holding the shaft and stabbing into the slopes with the pick, usually with two axes. (Piolet appui, or “middle dagger”). This method, paired with that equipment, is much more efficient and safe than old school "high-dagger" mode, which is a derivative of self-belay grip. (In 60º+ terrain, you're no longer in a "classic mountaineering" context; you're technical mountaineering (ice/mixed), usually with multi-pitch roped belays. This doesn't typically occur on Mount Whitney as there is very little terrain that qualifies...)


Do what you want, of course, but in terrain that matters, usage of self-belay grip is old-school, largely without merit and is a consequence multiplier. The first consequence is that you very likely cannot affect an immediate arrest when and where it actually matters. The second consequence is that you build up more speed than can be arrested. The consequences that follow are the many that occur when people fall uncontrollably down mountains.


Confidence on steep snow slopes comes from knowing you can arrest a fall if one occurs. Crampons on mountaineering boots and proper footwork are the first line of defense, but if that fails, and you're holding your axe in self-belay mode, you might not be able to stop a fall.


If you don’t know what the terms “pick”, “spike”, “adze”, self-arrest grip or self-belay grip are, AND you want to learn how (properly) glissade; have a read-through…

Dan in soft, slushy snow at the base of the couloir between Iceberg Lake and The Notch on the Mountaineers Route. He's wallowing about up to his knees. His ice axe plunge could go up to his elbow if he wanted it to. This is the end of the slope on our descent, but above, where it's steeper, you couldn't fall off that slope in those conditions if you tried. And we DID try (glissading, AKA "falling down a mountain"...) It was too wet and slushy, so we just plunge-stepped the entire couloir. And he's holding his ax in self-arrest grip...
Dan in soft, slushy snow at the base of the couloir between Iceberg Lake and The Notch on the Mountaineers Route. He's wallowing about up to his knees. His ice axe plunge could go up to his elbow if he wanted it to. This is the end of the slope on our descent, but above, where it's steeper, you couldn't fall off that slope in those conditions if you tried. And we DID try (glissading, AKA "falling down a mountain"...) It was too wet and slushy, so we just plunge-stepped the entire couloir. And he's holding his ax in self-arrest grip...
Patrick grinding up to Iceberg Lake. Holding his ax in self-arrest grip because you can't self-arrest from self-belay grip...
Patrick grinding up to Iceberg Lake. Holding his ax in self-arrest grip because you can't self-arrest from self-belay grip...
John on the summit of Rainier. STILL holding his ax in self-arrest grip...
John on the summit of Rainier. STILL holding his ax in self-arrest grip...
My wife and Carman bootin' up Baldy Bowl. Self-arrest grip...
My wife and Carman bootin' up Baldy Bowl. Self-arrest grip...
Zach ascending the Slope To Climber's Right. Holding his ax in self-arrest grip because you can't self-arrest from self-belay grip...
Zach ascending the Slope To Climber's Right. Holding his ax in self-arrest grip because you can't self-arrest from self-belay grip...